A Self-Assessment of this Semester

This summer has been spent thinking about assessment and more importantly, how to assess my students in a way that benefits their overall learning the most. I started this summer by posting three thoughts about assessment, and I have returned to those thoughts every couple of weeks. Now, as the summer draws to a close and I am preparing for the start of a new year I have an updated, reworked, perspective on assessment. If you would like to read that first blog post you can find it here.

Having completed the work focused on assessment I have three new ideas. First, my feedback should result in students understanding their learning more deeply. Second, it is critical that I allow my students to assess their own work and the work of their peers. And third, the assessments I give should work together to give an overview of how student learning has developed over time. Some of these ideas are similar to my original three beliefs, but I feel my assessments in this new year will be more beneficial to my students than they have been previously. 

In the first iteration of my beliefs about assessment I stated that “assessment should not be final,” but I have adjusted that thought to look more at how my feedback affects students’ overall learning. This allows for the possibility that an assessment can be final, but still emphasizes the importance of my feedback, specifically emphasizing that my feedback leads to the next possible learning step (Hattie & Temperly, 2007). Nicol and Macfarlane-Dick (2006) explain how critical it is for both the student and the teacher to have a shared understanding of the objective and how the student’s work is aligned with that objective. My feedback is an opportunity to align the objective and the student’s work when a student does not perform well, and then provide an opportunity for that student to make a new attempt at demonstrating their learning. But just providing feedback is not enough; after students receive feedback and additional instruction, they need an opportunity to demonstrate their new learning. Sams and Bergmann (2013) give students multiple opportunities to retake an assessment if they are unhappy about their performance. With quality feedback, and multiple opportunities to demonstrate new learning assessment is not punitive, and ultimately supports overall student learning. While I still agree that assessment should not be final my work this semester has proven how critical it is that my feedback supports, encourages, and guides student learning so that when they are given the chance to retake an assessment they understand what they got wrong the first time, why they got it wrong, and how to fix it next time. Just giving students a chance to retake an assessment is not enough, my feedback has to serve as a support for their ongoing learning.

My second belief is that a student’s self-assessment is critical. This is the evolution of my prior belief that students should be involved. I think the root of each of these statements is the same, but I feel it is necessary that my focus shift from thinking the student only needs to be involved in the outcome of their assessment to the student being responsible for the assessment itself. This self-assessment begins by students being able to explain what they are doing, why they are doing it, how their work will help them, and ultimately how they will show they have learned the intended lesson (Wiggins & McTighe, 2005). If students are not able to explain those elements of their work then they will not be able to assess that work. To support their understanding of why they are doing work and how it will help them adding reflective journals and self-reflection is important to the overall body of assessment as Shepard (2000) argues, and supports as simply being good teaching practice. Reflective journaling gives students the chance to think through the work they are doing and demonstrates to me their understanding of the work. It provides additional context for my assessment and extends the data I am able to collect about their overall learning. As a starting point, students need to learn how to assess the work they are doing, but starting with self-assessment might not be the most effective introduction to this process. Nicol and Macfarlane-Dick suggest introducing students to self-assessment by allowing them to assess their peers’ work first. This provides some separation from the work itself and begins to teach the students to be objective about the quality of the work. 

My third belief about assessment is a complete departure from the first draft of these three beliefs. Previously I explained that assessment should inform me as much about my performance as a teacher as my students’ performance on the assessment. And while I should still consider how well I explained and taught the material, that is not one of the most important considerations of assessment as a whole. It is more important that the assessments I give fit together as a larger body of work to demonstrate student learning. One assessment is not enough to demonstrate a student’s successful mastery of new content or to determine their failure to master that content. However, taking diverse work samples, like a student portfolio that allows for larger reflections about a student’s growth and their strengths is a better assessment of their performance (Niguidula, 2005). And there are great benefits for students when their work is a part of a portfolio as well. Black and Wiliam (1998) explain how students can be more motivated when their work is a part of a portfolio that emphasizes growth rather than singular summative assessments. A portfolio supports student learning and encourages more meaningful feedback because student growth is the focus rather than a grade at the end of an assessment. Additionally, when students work to create a collection of work it can provide a context for their learning. I remember cramming for tests in high school and college then quickly forgetting everything I committed to short term memory. I had no context for the learning and spent my time simply memorizing facts that meant very little to me. It is important that students understand the context of their learning, especially as they move from my elementary classroom to middle and high school classrooms. Reading assessments so often focuses on answering questions about the words in a story without considering the context of those words. Gee (2003) uses the example of a basketball player dribbling up the court with two fingers raised. While a reader might be able to answer a question about what the player is doing, or how many fingers he raised, if the reader does not understand basketball and the strategy that is involved in calling a play then the actual meaning of that sentence is lost. Building a portfolio of work over time, and reviewing that portfolio periodically can give more context to the assessments students complete.

The biggest change came in my third belief. Throughout the semester the readings I completed, and the work that went along with them, did not support the idea that assessment should serve as an indicator of my performance as a teacher. While I think I should consider my role in student performance, that is not one of the most important parts of assessment as a whole. I have not used portfolios consistently enough through my career for them to come to mind as I created the first list of beliefs, but after reading multiple authors talk about how beneficial they can be, and reflecting on the few times I have successfully created portfolios of student work, I think this is an important addition. The focus on growth is my favorite part of portfolios. Encouraging students to continue working to improve their previous scores has always felt like an uphill struggle, but I think implementing a primarily summative assessment method made that work feel defeating to students. If the assessment method encouraged growth then my additional encouragement would support the purpose of the assessment (this idea has been growing from early this summer). Additionally, I am more convinced of the importance of students having the time to reflect on their learning. Last year my principal pushed for more reflective writing as an ordinary part of student’s daily work. I tried to build it in periodically, but I did not see the benefit and frequently pushed that part of my lesson plan to provide more time for in class practice. After seeing the research that supports having students reflect on their learning I regret not devoting more time to student reflection, even in a math classroom. My work this summer has convinced me that students will retain their learning more after reflective assessments, and I will have a better understanding of my student’s learning when I read those reflections. And my work on a formative assessment has helped me implement some of the benefits that technology allows for when providing feedback. In that Twitter thread I talk about the importance of students being able to read and write in order to make effective use of some of the affordances in Google Docs, but using Flipgrid makes it so much easier for an elementary student because both the student and I can record our message without having to type it out and then read it. 

I am sure it is not a coincidence that the two most influential assignments this semester were designed to be completed in three iterations with feedback provided frequently. The Assessment Design Checklist has helped to solidify these three beliefs about assessment. While an assessment may not hit all five of my questions, it is a good guide to help determine how effective an assessment I am planning to use might be. And if an assessment does not most of those questions the ADC serves as a guide to determine what additions or alterations might be needed to make an assessment more meaningful. As I prepare for the start of a new school year I am excited about introducing numberless word problems through the Formative Assessment Design I created. This ongoing assessment is an ongoing body of work designed to demonstrate student growth over the course of the semester and respond to student needs as they are apparent through their work. Each day students record a quick assessment of their own work, and compare it to the assessment of a peer’s work, and it allows me to provide feedback to students then give them a chance to demonstrate their learning after receiving that feedback. The development of these three beliefs informed the creation of my FAD. Recently, I worked on creating a game that could be used to assess my students focused on the events leading up to the American Revolution. That assessment is still very much a work in progress, but as I designed the game I tried to link the frames so that an “incorrect” response would lead the player to a screen with feedback attempting to point them back in the right direction. I am still working on how I might better incorporate student self-assessment and reflections, but for now, having a tight feedback loop is a good start. 

This course was a great course for me this summer. I needed the space to really think about assessment and work through so many different iterations of my own work to come to a more solid understanding of what assessment is. That would have been more challenging during a semester. I would have tried to implement ideas that were not fully formed and the eventual undesirable outcomes would have been disheartening for me. Having the time and space to really work through what I think about assessment and how I can alter my practice has been good for me, and more importantly, it will benefit my students this year.

 

References:

Black, P. & Wiliam, D. (1998). Assessment and Classroom Learning. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 5(1), 7-74.

Gee, J. P. (2003). What video games have to teach us about learning and literacy. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77(1), 81–112.

Nicol, D., & Macfarlane-Dick, D. (2006). Formative assessment and self-regulated learning: A model and seven principles of good feedback practice. Studies in Higher Education, 31(2), 199–218.

Niguidula, D. (2005). Documenting learning with digital portfolios. Educational Leadership, 63(3), 44-47.

Sams, A., & Bergmann, J. (2013). Flip your students’ learning. Educational Leadership, 70(6), 16-20.

Shepard, Lorrie A. (2000). The role of assessment in a learning culture. Educational Researcher 29(7), p. 4-14.

Wiggins, G. P. & McTighe, J. (2005). Understanding by design. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.

 

(Re)Refining the Numberless Word Problems Assessment

At the start of every school year, I struggle to understand why so many of my students’ first thought when solving word problems is to simply pick a mathematical process and plug in the numbers provided in a word problem. I have tried to reason, beg, implore, and bribe my students into reading each word problem then stop to actually think about what that problem means. I’ve tried to encourage them to draw a picture or act it out, and as long as we focus on one isolated problem they successfully figure out what process the problem requires. However, that does not translate to a more formal assessment or even a problem they work independently just moments later! They slide back into the old habit of picking a process and plugging in the numbers. Then, I stumbled across numberless word problems.

The Purpose of this Assessment

When students are presented with a word problem without numbers they more naturally begin thinking about the events in the problem as though they were taking place in the real world. More simply, students have an easier time imagining the actions in the word problem when the numbers are absent, and when students can imagine the actions actually taking place they have an easier time understanding what mathematical function works best for that problem. Once students have a solid image of the actions in the word problem the numbers can be added back into that problem. My experiences with word problems lead me to believe that the numbers are the primary focus when students begin reading a problem. My goal is to shift their focus from the numbers to the situation being presented. 

The basic layout of the numberless word problem is broken down into four different slides (you can view this assessment here):

  1. The word problem with no numbers,
  2. The word problem with one number added in,
  3. The word problem with all of the numbers,
  4. And the complete word problem including the question.

Before students see any of the numbers in the problem (slide 1) I ask them to sketch a picture of the problem. This process helps students visualize the problem and talk about their thinking more effectively. After students sketch the problem each slide adds additional information (slides 2 and 3) to the problem slowly to give a more complete picture of the scenario. Initially, this protects students from being overwhelmed by too much new information at once; it gives them time to continue their thinking by checking how reasonable their first idea of the problem was. When students reach the final slide (slide 4) they should be prepared to solve the problem and justify their answer.

These assessments slow down student’s work and guides them into actually thinking about the math presented in each word problem. I believe most students struggle with word problems because they cannot imagine the problem in a concrete way, so they cannot set up the problem correctly,  rather than not being able to actually solve the problem itself. The numberless word problem is intended to teach students how to read a word problem and accurately set up math work. It assumes they are already able to solve the problem once it is set up.

Assessment Instructions for Learners

To help keep my thoughts organized I wrote out a full set of student instructions here.

Students will be divided into three groups with each group having five members. This will allow each student to work on one new problem each day of the week so that every member solves all five problems by Friday, and responds to the first video post for each of the five-word problems. 

For the first few weeks of this assessment, I will demonstrate how to record a Flipgrid video, title it correctly, and respond to the correct video until students understand how the process works. In time they will be able to do this naturally, but until they have worked through the process a few times I will guide them through each step.

The Links between Assessment and Instruction

Before students begin this five-day assessment cycle, I will introduce numberless word problems and the process I expect them to follow when solving them. The week before they are assigned the first full assessment I will solve two problems a day as a whole group where I work the problem with the class one step at a time and explain my thinking as I go. Based on my previous experiences students only need to see a few examples before they are ready to work a numberless word problem on their own. After two days of working problems together students are ready to solve these problems independently, so the following week will be the beginning of the full assessment.

The content of the first two or three cycles of these problems will be fairly basic (addition and subtraction in fifth grade should not cause any problems for my students), so I do not anticipate teaching any content through these problems. The first few weeks are targeted at teaching students to think through the process of solving word problems. After seeing student work on Monday, by observing their work moving around the room and watching their Flipgrid videos, I will be able to respond to common mistakes in my instruction the next day. Before students begin working on their numberless word problem on Tuesday, my instruction will be targeted at reviewing the process students should follow by working an example on the board. My work will include some of the mistakes I observed on Monday, and I will ask students to correct my mistakes as I work the problem on the board. And if there are students that seem to need more help than that I will meet with them in a small group before they begin working on their assigned problem, or even work the problem out with them to provide more support if that is what they need. 

After completing three weeks of this assessment cycle my focus will shift from the process of solving the problem to the content. The five assigned word problems will contain an assortment of content (addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, etc.) so I will respond to my students’ work at the start of the following week. Throughout the week I will record students’ responses to each problem so that I can collect data about each student’s understanding of the processes being assessed. At the beginning of the next week, I will design my instruction to respond to that data. If the majority of the class missed a division problem my instruction will be with the whole group to review word problems that require division to solve it. However, if only a small group of students needs that instruction I will plan to meet with only the students who solved the problems incorrectly. And after providing instruction in response to the data I collect the groups for the new week will be arranged based on the data I collected. For example, groups A and B might move onto a new set of problems focused on adding fractions, while group C reviews division word problems after receiving additional instruction in a small group.

Providing Feedback to Students

Ultimately, giving feedback to students that leads to them better understand the content is foundational to any assessment. I will be able to provide feedback in two ways, by responding to their Flipgrid posts and in-person meetings in the classroom. I think both methods of feedback are effective, but for different situations. A Flipgrid response seems to be the best option for responding to students who seem to get it. I will be able to quickly affirm a student’s correct work through a video response, and by uploading a screencast where I speak about a student’s work I can ask questions that introduce new ideas. This method of feedback leads students to “greater possibilities of learning” (Hattie and Temperly, 2007). When students demonstrate that they understand the process and the content of the questions my feedback can begin leading them to the next thing. Responding to their work through a Flipgrid response will be ideal as it is individualized based on their level of understanding. 

Meeting with students in-person, whether individually or in a small group, is best saved for responding to incorrect student work. Nicol and Macfarlane-Dick (2006) explain that feedback intended to help students understand their mistakes and then troubleshoot their own work is a critical component of meaningful feedback. Responding to the students either individually or in small groups based on common mistakes allows me to provide that sort of feedback. Gathering data through observation and viewing Flipgrid videos will give me the data I need to determine which method of feedback is best for each student, and then plan instruction based on those needs. 

Integrating Technology

Using Flipgrid for these lessons might be a time-consuming process, but it serves a couple different purposes. First, it supports students’ conversations about their work with each other. I will have to teach this process at first, but after the first few weeks where the process of this assessment is the primary focus, students should begin to understand how to explain their own work and respond to their peers’ work. Flipgrid allows students to review their videos and redo anything they are not satisfied with. And because they can rewatch videos that are already posted they have a chance to really understand how other students solved the problem they just worked on. Additionally, if two students solve the same problem in a different way I can take their videos and use them as an example of how a problem might have two different, but equally correct, solutions.

I also benefit from using Flipgrid in these lessons. It is difficult to speak with each student often enough to really understand their thinking in the time I have with them each day, but using Flipgrid extends that conversation beyond the scheduled school day. I can review student’s posts to get a better understanding of how they are thinking about their work and I can group them more accurately because my data goes beyond correct and incorrect answers. My feedback can be targeted at how they are thinking about their work so address different thinking which might result in the same incorrect response.

Resources:

Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77(1), 81–112.

Nicol, D., & Macfarlane-Dick, D. (2006). Formative assessment and self-regulated learning: A model and seven principles of good feedback practice. Studies in Higher Education, 31(2), 199–218.

 

Lost in France

I am getting ready to play through a classmate’s Twine game. His game is designed for use in an introductory French class, and after reading through his description of the game I am preparing myself to “lose” this particular game. It may not be designed to be a game with a winner and a loser, but I’m likely going to lose anyway with only the most basic understanding of the French language. 

Throughout the game there is a solid mixture of English only answer choices and french only answer choices, I was able to work my way through the game with the English answer choices pretty successfully. The most surprising thing about this game is how quickly I found myself picturing my high school language classroom as though this game were actually being played out in my reality (though I took Spanish in high school). I expected to feel completely lost playing this game, and only make progress after narrowing down incorrect answers, but the design of the game provides feedback in a way that makes it easy for the student to understand their mistake as they play. The slide following an incorrect answer gives feedback to the player explaining the mistake made and supports the correct answer without overtly answering the question for the player, so I was able to correct my mistakes even with no previous instruction. 

The game does require the player to have a basic understanding of the french language to really feel confident playing through. I guessed and used as much of the context as I could to work through each slide, but with previous instruction, the review of this game seems to be intended for would be great. It is pretty easy to understand if you got the answer correct or not based on the slide following your answer. If the previous answer choice was correct the game continued with a new action, and if you were incorrect the player found themselves looking at the rest of the class doing something different or a slide giving a more detailed explanation of what should have been done before. The primary consequence of not understanding a slide was being redirected back to that slide after getting a little more information. It seemed that extra information was at most two slides, so the player was back at the question quickly.

I really enjoyed this game, and the use of gifs was an enjoyable part of each slide, even if they were just there to make the gameplay more enjoyable. I was surprised by the amount of environment I was able to pull from the game, but that might be the product of playing language-based games where it is my responsibility to image the environment as a player. 

Based on the Assessment Design Checklist I created early this summer, this would be an effective assessment in a classroom. It is clear the game is aligned to the curriculum, and by adding a question on a Google Form like the author indicated in his original blog it would be easy to determine if the students understood the purpose of the game as an assessment. Teacher feedback is complicated with a Twine game because you are not able to easily track a student’s progress through the game. However, I think adding the Google Forms would help the teacher understand how a student is progressing and where they are having difficulty. It might be as easy as having a student answer a single question after an incorrect response to indicate which slide gave them the most trouble. The last two points in my ADC look at how an assessment fits into the larger framework of a student’s work over the year as well as material outside of that classroom’s curriculum. Adding something from French history would allow for cross-curricular connections to be made in the game, and it seems that the introductory vocabulary could still be built into the game. Perhaps the player could be a member of a military advisory panel for Napoleon and they would stand and raise their hand in salute when he entered the room. Then the slides could progress to explain a historical event while students practice with the vocabulary. 

As it is, I think this game is designed very well, and it is easy to understand how to play even with a very limited understanding of the language. If anything were to be adjusted, I might suggest giving less help following an incorrect answer so that the student has a chance to really think about why their answer was incorrect, but that might not be helpful in the long run. Having never taught a language it might be better for the student to know right away what their answer should have been.

This french lesson felt like a great way to experience high school language all over again. I cannot claim to understand any french, but this game was designed to support the student and there is feedback built into the basic design. Well done.

 

Spinning up a Twine

Some of my favorite lessons over the last few years were built around a role playing campaign similar to role playing games like Dungeons and Dragons. One of these lessons focused on elements of fictional stories. Students worked in small groups to create a character that played a role in the story, and as we played the game as a class, we could have a discussion about the features of a fictional story. Because students were actively engaged in the story they felt the tension of rising action and the relief that comes with the conflict’s resolution.

Teaching history to elementary students is challenging, in part because they have such a limited ability to relate personally to lessons that should be learned from the historical stories they are told. For example, they might be able to explain what happened at the Boston Tea Party, but would not be able to explain why a national government might expect strong opposition if it were to heavily tax an item consumed by a small portion of its population. These lessons are more easily understood through a game where students assume the character in the historical story and “experience” that story so that the lesson is more relatable.

To build on the idea of using games as a form of assessment, I am looking at the events that led up to the American Revolution and how I might teach that portion of history to my fifth-grade class next year. This is the context of my game (or the Semiotic Domain I am working within) where students will demonstrate an understanding of the internal and external grammar related to this context. For students to be successful in this game they will need to understand the events that led to the American Revolution (the internal grammar) and then apply those ideas to the situation they face in the game. After completing the game students will complete an open ended reflection where they report on the events of the game as though they were a historian. They will be asked to explain the situation that the miners faced as they moved from their home, the dangers of living in a new area, and the pressure placed on the mining community because of those dangers. Students will explain why the mining community requested help from the leader of their home community, as well as the frustration the miners felt at being forced to pay for that help. This work will imitate the work of historians who explained the events that led to the American Revolution. The final question on this assessment will ask students to compare their experience in the game to the events that caused such frustration for the colonists.

 

The Game

The game will be set in a fantasy world where people are ruled by a distant leader (Elder Gregor) and work jobs like cutting wood, mining, and farming. The character is a miner who has just received news that he, and his fellow miners, will be moved to a distant part of the kingdom to continue mining. In order to support the farmers and woodsmen, the mining community will be forced to pay a “distance” tax due to the increased cost of transporting the stone and metal they mine, as well as the food and building materials they will require. Here the characters will begin making choices about how to respond.

The decisions they make will be similar to those of the original colonists. They might begin by accepting the taxes and continue working until the financial pressures become too much for them to tolerate, or they might rebel and refuse to pay the tax from the beginning. Their choices will have an impact on the kingdom and the king will respond. The conclusion of the game will allow the character to make a series of demands of the king to work out a compromise that each side can live with. These compromises will be based more on the external grammar of how a government and its people relate to each other.

This game is not the entire assessment of the events that led up to the American Revolution, but only a part of it. Leading into the game students will have been assessed on their knowledge of the actual events in American History and the results of those events. And following the game, they will respond through a reflective assessment to the similarities and differences of the Colonists with the miners. The game provides an experience aimed at helping students understand the context of the events that preceded the American Revolution. 

Earlier this summer I worked to create this five question assessment checklist to determine how effective my assessments are. As an assessment, this game addresses, at least in part, all five of the questions on the checklist. The purpose of the game is tied to a real world situation, and the objective should be clear as it will be explained in the context of the lessons focused on the events that led to the American Revolution. Allowing for each player to make choices based on their understanding of those events checks for student’s understanding of the objectives I taught in the previous lessons, and since each of those choices leads to a new “event” in the game I am able to provide feedback based on what happens in the game. As this game does not allow students to fully explain the details of this historical period it will have to be a portion of a larger collection of work, that together demonstrates student’s complete understanding. And in order for students to complete this game successfully, they will have to transfer their prior learning into the decisions they make within the game.

Students are faced with a few decisions, but the game really begins to imitate the events the colonists faced when the student asks for aid from Elder Gregor. The player has to decide if they will take the aid and the increased financial pressure that comes with it, or try to protect themselves. The game tells students that the miners will have to pay, house, and feed the army. This is just like the quartering act the colonists faced. And in their reflection students will explain the pressure this would put on the miners and compare that to the colonists. 

After players view the video of the voice mail the colonists left King George, the game would continue by having them decide what their frustration is in order to send a letter to Elder Gregor. They are faced with four choices of what might be frustrating the miners, only one of those choices is similar to the frustrations the colonists felt. This section of the game acts as a quick assessment  with the three incorrect answers leading back to the assessment question, and having the student raise their hand so that I can speak with them. This lets me know what the student is thinking and have a quick conversation with them, so that I can provide immediate feedback and correct any misunderstanding that student might have before moving on. Additionally, if I notice a large section of my class missing the same question I can make a note of the question giving them the most trouble and discuss it at the conclusion of the game. Though I am not able to pull data from my students’ responses as though it were a Google Form, I can observe and give feedback to their responses in the in-game assessment.

As students continue they will be faced with more choices set up similarly to this one, so that I can assess their understanding while they are playing the game. One benefit of this format is that a wrong answer is redirected back to the original question, and the student is given another opportunity to answer correctly after receiving feedback from me. Before students complete their reflection of the game I have the chance to speak with them about their choices as a mining community. The reflection continues this assessment by asking them to transfer their experience in the game to explain their understanding of the events the American Colonists experienced. 

The information I gather through these assessment points will give me the data I need to direct future lessons. In the days following the game I will be able to either group students based on the questions they responded incorrectly to, or lead a whole group lesson focused on a question that most of the class missed. And when combined with the reflection questions completed at the conclusion of the game I will have a clear picture of what students understood, and where they still need instruction.

Preparing to Twine

Some of my favorite lessons over the last few years were built around a role playing campaign similar to role playing games like Dungeons and Dragons. One of these lessons focused on the elements of fictional stories. Students worked in small groups to create a character that played a role in the story, and as we played the game as a class, we could have a discussion about the features of a fictional story. Because students were actively engaged in the story they felt the tension of  rising action and the relief that comes with the conflict’s resolution.

Teaching history to elementary students is challenging, in part because they have such a limited ability to relate personally to lessons that should be learned from the historical stories they are told. For example, they might be able to explain what happened at the Boston Tea Party, but would not be able to explain why a national government might expect strong opposition if it were to heavily tax an item consumed by a small portion of its population. These lessons are more easily understood through a game where students assume the character in the historical story and “experience” that story so that the lesson is more relatable.

To build on the idea of using games as a form of assessment, I am looking at the events that led up to the American Revolution and how I might teach that portion of history to my fifth-grade class next year. This is the context of my game (or the Semiotic Domain I am working within) where students will demonstrate an understanding of the internal and external grammar related to this context. For students to be successful in this game they will need to understand the events that led to the American Revolution (the internal grammar) and then apply those ideas to the situation they face in the game. At the conclusion of the game, the players will work through a series of responses to a controlling government making demands for change that will lead to a more productive relationship between the government and the people.

The Game

The game will be set in a fantasy world where people are ruled by a king and work jobs like cutting wood, mining, and farming. The character is a miner who has just received news that he, and his fellow miners, will be moved to a distant part of the kingdom to continue mining. In order to support the farmers and woodsmen, the mining community will be forced to pay a “distance” tax due to the increased cost of transporting the stone and metal they mine, as well as the food and building materials they will require. Here the characters will begin making choices about how to respond.

The decisions they make will be similar to those of the original colonists. They might begin by accepting the taxes and continue working until the financial pressures become too much for them to tolerate, or they might rebel and refuse to pay the tax from the beginning. Their choices will have an impact on the kingdom and the king will respond. The conclusion of the game will allow the character to make a series of demands of the king to work out a compromise that each side can live with. These compromises will be based more on the external grammar of how a government and its people relate to each other.

This game is not the entire assessment of the events that led up to the American Revolution, but only a part of it. Leading into the game students will have been assessed on their knowledge of the actual events in American History and the results of those events. And following the game, they will respond through a reflective assessment to the similarities and differences of the Colonists with the miners. The game provides an experience aimed at helping students understand the context of the events that preceded the American Revolution. 

Earlier this summer I worked to create this five question assessment checklist to determine how effective my assessments are. As an assessment, this game addresses, at least in part, all five of the questions on the checklist. The purpose of the game is tied to a real world situation, and the objective should be clear as it will be explained in the context of the lessons focused on the events that led to the American Revolution. Allowing for each player to make choices based on their understanding of those events checks for student’s understanding of the objectives I taught in the previous lessons, and since each of those choices leads to a new “event” in the game I am able to provide feedback based on what happens in the game. As this game does not allow students to fully explain the details of this historical period it will have to be a portion of a larger collection of work, that together demonstrates student’s complete understanding. And in order for students to complete this game successfully, they will have to transfer their prior learning into the decisions they make within the game.

 

A Get to Know You of Sorts

As the summer begins to draw to an end I have started planning for the beginning of a new school year and all of the changes that come with a new job. This year I will be using Google Classroom, a new (to me) CMS (Course Management System). As I work to understand how to make the best use of the CMS I will also be teaching my fifth-grade students how to navigate the course as this will be their first time using Google Classroom as well.

The first assessment I created for my class is a math pre-assessment. This assessment will give me a clearer understanding of what my students know coming into the beginning of the school year and what misconceptions they are bringing with them. It focuses on the four major processes (addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division), and asks them to find a mistake in a problem that I worked and recorded. While this is not a full assessment of what I anticipated they learned in the years before entering my classroom, it will serve as the foundation for my mathematics instruction. Any gaps or misunderstandings found in this pre-assessment must be corrected before moving into the fifth-grade curriculum. And I feel confident if students can accurately solve each problem in this pre-assessment they are ready for everything I will teach this year.

This assessment is motivated largely by my experiences last year where some students entered my classroom performing at an eighth-grade level and others struggling to add and subtract. I was not prepared for such a wide ability gap, and I wished that I was more prepared from the start of the year. Having data that shows what my students know coming into the new school year will help me be more prepared to plan effective lessons and begin grouping my students.

One benefit of giving this assessment through my Google Classroom is the ability to copy and reassign it after students have had time to work through the first few weeks of the school year. This pre-assessment is designed to be formative, so students that do not earn 100% on their first attempt will have the opportunity to return to it again to demonstrate their new learning as the year progresses. Introducing the purpose of pre-assessment in my classroom early is another key aspect of this assignment. Even as early as fifth-grade students struggle to understand that a pre-assessment does not affect their grade, but gives me the information I need to teach them most effectively. Teaching my students the purpose of pre-assessment this early in the school year is just as important as the data I will gather from their actual work.

I created this short video to explain this assessment and my thinking in a little more detail.

This assessment is naturally aligned with the objectives that I will be teaching throughout the school year as the skills assessed are the foundation of all of the content in fifth grade math. One of the key features of this assessment is how I will use it to group students based on their needs. The results of the electronic assessment, and the work they turn in from the paper will begin to inform me about each student’s strengths and weaknesses in math. After working through small group instruction, students will have the chance to retake the pre-assessement to demonstrate their growth and eventual mastery of these foundational skills. While one purpose of this assessment is to discover how prepared each student is for the fifth grade mathematics curriculum, I am more interested in them understanding how I will use pre-assessments throughout the entirety of the school year. One of the reflection questions at the end of the assessment asks students to explain how and why I will be using pre-assessments. It is important to me that each student understands that they are not graded, and their performance on these pre-assessments are designed to show growth as we work through our lessons.

This assessment provides feedback as soon as students submit the assessment, but beyond that, I will provide feedback as soon as I group students based on the data I receive. The groups I form will be targeted at each student’s needs based on their performance on the pre-assessment. The lessons I plan for the small group instruction will be targeted at any misconceptions that are identified, or if students demonstrate mastery of the pre-assessment, new content. For each student, this is only the beginning of their work in my class, regardless of how well they do on the pre-assessment, and it will be used to demonstrate their growth over the year. This is the first piece of work that I will have, so as I conference with the students, or their family, this pre-assessment will be the starting point for those conversations. This pre-assessment is the beginning of each student’s math portfolio. 

Perhaps the most important aspect of this assessment is the common language that will stem from it. One of the biggest challenges for me last year was working through a math problem with a struggling student only to find they did not understand a piece of the math vocabulary. As I build on the skills taught in the fourth grade, I plan to reference these questions as “common vocabulary” with each student. Reviewing these problems, perhaps even using them as anchor charts, will allow me to connect their future learning to their new learning later in the semester.

 

More than Just Quizzes

I am continuing to consider assessment this week and the tools that are available to use as an assessment. Today, I have selected Schoology as CMS (Classroom Management System) to review the assessment features. Many of the features available in Schoology look like the typical assessment, but a few had surprising uses.

Assessment categories:

  1. Quiz/Test – The quiz or test feature in Schoology is exactly what its name implies, either a quiz or a test. You have the option or matching, multiple choice, fill in the blank, short answer, or essay questions. This covers the range of possible quizzes or tests all in one place. A few benefits of this feature are immediate student feedback (multiple choice, fill in the blank, matching), being able to assign quizzes or tests to individual students or groups, and limiting time or giving multiple opportunities to take the assessment. However, being an electronic assessment allows students to leave the page and search for answers, and if students are not skilled typists a short answer or essay question could be very difficult for them to complete. Overall this is a very helpful feature in an elementary school classroom outside of the typing heavy questions. I especially like that students get instant feedback and I have access to data without having to organize it myself.
  2. Assignment – The add assignment feature allows you to either add an assignment from a Google Drive account or thought the Schoology page. This offers endless possibilities for assessment as students can create Docs, Slides, or Sheets through the Google Suite. Prompts can be added on the creation page or in the Google application being assigned. This is only beneficial if both the students and teachers have a Google account tied to their Schoology account. Again, being a skilled typist is very helpful in using this app. A huge benefit of this feature is how easily feedback can be added within the Google applications. And as with all of the assignment features in Schoology, this can be hidden from the students until it is assigned, or only be assigned to groups of selected students or individuals. This feature is best used for open-ended work like research or reflections. I think it is especially useful for reflection as it can be organized like a journal where the conversation between teacher and student is private.
  3. Add File/Link/External Tool – This feature allows you to add something from outside of the CMS for the class to access. Adding a file gives students access to a PDF or document saved on your computer, adding a link takes students to a separate website, and an external tool can be linked to the Schoology account for class use. This can be useful, but if too many files or links are added to a Schoology page it can easily get overwhelming and confusing for students. Too many different pages to sort through can lead to information being missed or overlooked unintentionally. It is beneficial in that you are able to add materials to your page without having to create something over again. This feature can be best used to have students view a website or video and then respond to what they viewed. It can also be used to support lessons taught or to flip the classroom by linking to sites like Khan Academy for math instruction. This feature, while useful, is one that I have learned to use sparingly to avoid increasing the difficulty of use to students.
  4. Add Discussion – The discussion feature is great for students’ to post feedback to their peers’ work or respond to prompts about their learning. This is best used for reflective assessment. Some of the affordances of this feature are limiting the participants of the discussion, the option of the teacher to monitor the discussion up to the point of approving posts in the discussion forum, and all participants being able to respond to each other. External links can be posted to the discussion board adding value to the conversation by linking the conversation to outside websites. This is dependent on the participant’s ability type well, and their ability to monitor their own language as the tone is lost through the discussion board. I really like the ability for students to post pictures to the discussion board to show their work when that work is done on paper or built physically rather than created on the computer.
  5. Built in Messaging feature – There is a built in messaging feature in Schoology that acts like an in app email. While not a typical form of assessment this can be used to have conversations with students to check their understanding or to give additional assistance. One major benefit of this feature is the ability to have a conversation with a student privately. If a student asks a question through the messaging feature their classmates do not know it, so shy students might feel more comfortable asking for help through this feature. A major drawback is the ability for students to message each other without others knowing. 
  6. Updates – This feature allows the teacher to post a message to the class’ homepage where each student can view it. While not a typical idea of assessment this can be used to ask questions for students to reflect on or guide their thinking as they work on the assignments in the class. This might be similar to questions posed at the beginning of a unit or on the board at the beginning of a new lesson. One major affordance is how easily the teacher can respond to problems that might come up through a lesson. If they receive multiple questions from students focused on the same issue the teacher could post an update to give clarity to other students before they encounter that problem, or if more time is needed to complete an assignment it could be posted here or even an extra source that might help students. I have not considered how beneficial the update feature could be in the overall assessment process. The largest constraint is having students actually log in and check the update page. This feature would be best used to provide additional resources or ask questions that students can reflect on or respond to in their work.
  7. Gradebook – This feature allows the teacher to input student grades and students (or their parents) to view them. As an assessment, this can be used to help guide students’ formative work. The gradebook could be used to help students make decisions about which assignments they should return to for additional help, or when they are ready to move onto the next assignment. A teacher could use it to create groups for students to work in, or to assign differentiated materials to. Some of the quizzes or tests can have scores uploaded to the gradebook automatically so the chance of teacher input error is smaller and the gradebook is updated immediately. A drawback is how easily another student can view their peer’s gradebook by simply opening another student’s computer, or checking when a student walks away from their computer.
  8. Badges – The badges feature allows the teacher to assign a digital badge to a student or group of students to reward them for their work, effort, or anything else the teacher would like to award. While this should not be used as an indicator of a student’s grades it can be used as an assessment of their effort, behavior, or participation. This feature can be a good assessment tool to record and communicate a student’s work in a way that is unrelated to their actual score on an assignment. For example, many parents tell their students to “just do your best” in their school work. If a student were to earn a badge for their hard work or perseverance on an assignment they scored poorly on it would indicate their effort. A drawback is how time consuming this could be, and the number of badges that could be created in a classroom. The assigning of badges is often subjective and difficult to defend. 
  9. Attendance – This feature allows the teacher to track their class’ attendance by marking each student as absent, present, late, or excused. It can be used to keep track of when students were out of school to help organize late or missing work, and if a student is missing the beginning of school consistently it could be used as evidence for struggles with the material taught at the beginning of the school day. It is easy and quick to use.
  10. Workload Planning – This feature is presented as a table showing each student and the amount of work they have due on each day. It is color-coded by the number of assignments due, and the colors can be adjusted using a drop-down menu. This allows a teacher to quickly see how many assignments are due so that decisions can be made about due dates or adding extensions to assignments. It is incredibly helpful with planning to ensure that enough time is given for each assignment, especially when considering the amount of work students have to complete in all of their classes. 
  11. Nearpod – Though Nearpod is not connected to my Schoology class, this app can be connected to a Schoology class. This app allows teachers to add quizzes, lessons, polls, etc. to their class to create different assignments in engaging ways. One big drawback is the ability to connect Nearpod to your class, but when it is able to be connected it is a great way to adjust assignments for students. When I have been able to make use of Nearpod my students were very engaged which often makes assessment easier because I am not fighting the “why do I have to do this” battle.

 

Privacy Policy and Terms of Use:

After reading the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use there are not any features that I would avoid using. Parents participation in the Schoology class is limited to their student’s personal work, and they are not able to comment on other students materials. Since students are not able to share their work outside of Schoology their privacy is protected and I have always seen a Google account generated through a school district used to set up a student’s Schoology account, so their personal email or contact information is not used. It is always good practice to avoid using identifying information, such as a picture, in a profile, but with the privacy being limited to the teacher and students in each class, even that is not a large concern.

 

The Formative Process of Formative Assessment

This summer I have been working to develop a five question checklist that I can use to help determine if an assessment is beneficial to my students. The biggest focus that has come from this process is how each assessment allows my students to return to their work and make revisions. Each assessment should have a formative component to it.

Sure, there are times when a summative assessment is necessary, but those times are far less frequent than I have seen practiced. Most of the teachers I have worked with treat even daily work or homework as a “one-shot” assessment; there is not a chance for students to revise their work before the class moves on. I have tried to do better, but so often I find myself behind with grading and posting grades that when my students are able to return to their work we are already into the next unit. Not much of a formative assessment. 

But maybe that is the result of poor planning. If I had a better idea of how to use each of my assessments formatively from the start my students might benefit more from revising their work. 

Click here to view my final checklist. And if you would like to see the evolution of this document here is the first draft and the second draft.

 

Refining the Numberless Word Problems

Now that summer is beginning to fully set in, and the overwhelming exhaustion that hangs on after the conclusion of a school year has faded, I can begin to truly think about the beginning of the new school year. One of my first focuses will be working with my students to really understand mathematical word problems, and more importantly, begin to see how they might translate to their lives outside of my classroom. One of the most frustrating battles as a math teacher is knowing students can perform the functions necessary to solve the problem, but cannot identify those functions correctly after reading a word problem. It is the Thanos of my classroom, “[It] is inevitable.”

This is where numberless word problems come in. When students are presented with a word problem without numbers they more naturally begin thinking about the events in the problem as though they were taking place in the real world. More simply, students have an easier time imagining the actions in the word problem when the numbers are absent, and when students can imagine the actions actually taking place they have an easier time understanding what mathematical function works best for that problem. Once students have a solid image of the actions in the word problem the numbers can be added back into the problem. My experiences with word problems lead me to believe that the numbers are the primary focus when students begin reading a problem. My goal is to shift their focus from the numbers to the situation being presented.

The basic layout of the numberless word problem is broken down into four different slides:

  1. The word problem with no numbers,
  2. The word problem with one number added in,
  3. The word problem with all of the numbers,
  4. And the complete word problem including the question.

Before students see any of the numbers in the problem I ask them to sketch a picture of the problem. This process helps students visualize the problem and talk about their thinking more effectively. After students sketch the problem each slide adds additional information to the problem slowly to give a more complete picture of the scenario. Initially, this protects students from being overwhelmed by too much new information at once; it gives them time to continue their thinking by checking how reasonable their first idea of the problem was. When students reach the final slide they should be prepared to solve the problem and justify their answer.

For this assessment, I have collected five numberless word problems so that students have a new problem to solve each day. As of right now, my class next year has 15 students, so I am able to break students into three groups of five students. The groups will work together to solve the problems and provide feedback to their group mates. On the first day, each student in a group will be assigned a different problem so that all five problems are solved on the first day. Then, the students will rotate through the remaining four new problems each day for the remainder of the week so that each student solves all five problems throughout the week.

To conclude their work each day students will record and post a video to our class Flip Grid explaining the work they did to solve their problem and justify their work. Their video after the first day will be a response to another student’s work where they talk about the similarities or differences in how the problems were solved. And as students are working, I will have the opportunity to meet with students to provide feedback as well as respond to their Flip Grid posts.

This assessment is an effective way to determine how well students understand the application of mathematical processes. Through individual conferences and responses to Flip Grip posts, I will see a student’s thinking as they solve each problem and respond to the process they used as well as the actual content of the problem. And with a new problem, each day students have the opportunity to try again after receiving feedback from me and the other members of their group.

You can view the numberless word problems here and my student instructions here.

 

Please Leave Your Message After the Beep…

This week I watched my wife try to find the time to speak on the phone with one of her best friends. For two days they missed the other’s call by a few minutes and left a voice message (or sent a text which seems to have replaced voices messages largely) in hopes they would find a time both were free to talk. Each time a call was missed the cycle started over until finally, they were both free at the same time. Seeing the subtle frustration after each missed call left me thinking about how students must feel after turning in each assignment. Every day that goes by without feedback is the frustration of a missed call magnified many times over. And that is before the teacher moves on to the next lesson!

This week I added feedback as a critical element of my Assessment Design Checklist. I am continuing to work on these five questions to guide my selection of assessments in my classroom. The aim of this checklist is to ensure that the assessments I select benefit my students in a way that clearly supports their learning.

The question regarding feedback is focused on students correctly completing each task that is assessed. Being in the elementary classroom I find the most important part of my job is guaranteeing that students arrive at the correct answer, and when they do not that they are able to begin the self-assessment process necessary to adjust to those mistakes. The second addition to this checklist looks at student choice in assessment. More than one assessment method allows students to choose how they want to demonstrate their learning, as well as an assessment to return to after receiving feedback if more work is needed.

The checklist is still a work in progress, but my hope is for these four questions to focus on different aspects of each assessment so that when they are combined they maximize the effectiveness of my students’ work.